January 25, 2010 3 Comments
One of the more annoying side effects of the leftish side of the blogosphere remaining so quiet about the “Ellie Light” fracas is that they have much longer memories than I do about various ‘astroturfing’ incidents, and they could contribute to a discussion about this far better than I’ll be able to.
So what is astroturfing? This was one of the examples that I was thinking of:
Last month, Rep. Ed Markey (D-MA) announced a congressional investigation of the DC lobbying firm Bonner & Associates. The firm, which has a long history of astroturfing, was caught forging anti-clean energy reform letters — purportedly from groups representing women and people of color — to Congress.
When I think of “astroturf,” I think of something that is fake and pretending to be something it’s not. Politically, it is a corporation or political organization pretending to be individual members of the public. They pretend to be individuals who have spontaneously decided to speak out and have no apparent connection to the organization.
I doubt that “Ellie Light” is connected to a corporation or organization, along the lines of what Ann Althouse has said, because a skilled astroturfer just wouldn’t be so stupid. So “Ellie Light” doesn’t really fit the definition. I think that “Ellie Light” used a version of ‘astroturf’ tactics by pretending to speak as a local resident, but I find it hard to believe at this point that there was encouragement or payment for such a deceitful and poorly executed stunt.